It’s fantastic!
It’s so fun to gift around and no one gets salty if they don’t get what they want, which is how gifting threads should be :D
It’s amazing and I’ve gotten some good stuff from it, thank you!

You have liked this post!

Love it although I do experience the same problems as everyone else. You send something worth a lot but only receive a carcass expiring soon. Not a huge deal, I guess. Like you mentioned, it's not a karma thing although it is really frustrating sometimes. It's also kind of difficult if someone only wants things worth over a GB and doesn't put anything else on their list. I don't think too many other people have had this problem but sometimes, I don't actually receive anything back from the person below me? I've only experienced this a small number of times though. Someone probably just forgot. Other than those problems, the gifting sub is great

You have liked this post!

I do like the thread, as it helps redistribute everything. However, my major complaint is the fact that its mainly the same people. As such, if there's someone online giving away muties and stuff, the same people get them. Another thing is sometimes players say they send a gift, but don't. Often times I do think it is an accident, but when this does happen to me I likely don't say anything cuz I'm way too anti-social/awkward for that.

You have liked this post!

I love the thread! The thing is, sometimes I'll be typing my list and as soon as I send someone else will too, so I either end up sending two gifts or not getting one,

You have liked this post!

Its been so helpful, ive been in this thread since i first started playing and everyone has been super nice to me!
But recently ive noticed some players making lists full or really hard items, nd also saying no surprises at the end, even though they ONLY send surprises

You have liked this post!

I’m starting to not like it since your barley online people are adding harder stuff and no easy stuff the staff are rarely online

You have liked this post!

Amazing thread! Love the idea, and love the “gamble” of what you get, if so fun

You have liked this post!

Im getting fed up with some people, especially the people who request high-quality items on their easy lists. Then, a lot of people complain when they don't get exactly what they want. Honestly, many people just need to realize that they should be grateful they even get something, whether that be on your list or not.

but otherwise, I love this thread <3

You have liked this post!

Loved it!! Recently got into gift threads and i find it fun like a gamble i guess LOL. Overall, this is my favorite thread so far 1 million stars out of ten! KIDDING- i give it a four because unfortunately despite a million pages it seems unactive :(( IT IS the best one i've come across tho!! hope it gets more active randomly!

You have liked this post!

Overall, this thread is an amazing concept, and i'd like it to be continued. But as many said above me, people are complaining left and right in the FORUM instead of pming each other, and it gets extremely confusing for me and other players.

Another thing is that the thread consists of the same people posting, it's not an entirely bad thing, but it would be nice to see some new people once in a while, which could be achieved through posting ads. There's also some rudeness and passive aggressiveness, plus inactive mods that aren't enforcing the rules listed above.

Also, I have the same complaint as other people. Everyone's list is full of hard items that aren't the easiest to obtain. Ex: Honeycomb, egg yolk, breeding items. While their easy list is: SB (500+) and GB. I'm not a new player, but I don't have that sort of currency to give away since I have my own things to save up for. I also agree with the "Newbie version" Idea. It would be nice to have a specific version for newer players, so other people don't get pissed off when they get 50 sb gifted to them.

Besides from that, I love this thread a lot and have been posting in it for a few years now, but I would like to see some changes. :)

You have liked this post!