" Critique will not really do much without making a working suggestion. Without it, it is just a rant and belongs to the rant board, but then again, Lioden-based issues arent allowed there. In order to make this to a suggestion, you will actually need to suggest. Dont just say that you are upset about the inheritance, but come up with a solution."

Haha, I'm not a game developer! My job is to tell if something needs fixing, not to code them a new system. Beta-players for beta-games are there to tell if something needs to be fixed and if so, how. As I'm not a beta player, I can very well tell if something doesn't seem right without providing a new source code to fix it. And like I said, I already suggested something done to the system so that birth stats work better than they work now (meaning, a lioness 300+ and a male 1600+ don't produce 400+ cubs when a lion 800+ and a lioness 700+ can't. Something should be done, and something more than just removing the boost from low stat females. AND, I already suggested a system that would calculate that a cub can't get a certain amount of % better than it's worst parent, making it more efficient to breed certain stats out of parents that are closer to each other in stats than a low stat x very high stat).

You have liked this post!

This is the Game Development board which is open to indeed critique and give them an idea what you want them to do. I am not the developer either and I have made a lot of suggestions. Suggesting is the way to show them your version of the solution.

Without suggesting, this is a rant.

Your current job isnt to code the new system but to tell them how you think the new system should look like.

It is bad criticism. Like an artwork. It is rude to tell the artist that his artwork sucks and he needs to get better without giving him an idea on how to do it. A good critique tells the artist what he needs to do to improve. So tell the developers how to improve the system by making a suggestion to make your critique full and actually valid.

You have liked this post!

There is a suggestion made, like I said.

You have liked this post!

I cannot see it in the first post.

You have liked this post!

I may edit it there later, but you can see it multiple times in other posts where this problem has been discussed further.

You have liked this post!

Omg yes, Spent gb on a 1000+ female, studded to a 1000+ male, all 500 cubs.... So angry

You have liked this post!